Sharing is caring!


  1. Christine says

    Is it absolutely necessary that it be made in a cast iron skillet or with a standard pie tin work, as long as its greased well?

  2. Lisa says

    This is going to be a reeeeeal problem for me. I can’t resist Nutella, and this looks AMAZING. I need to stop being friends with so many amazing baking bloggers 🙂

  3. Cheryl says

    Took on look at this on tumblr and decided to make it for Christmas presents. My only problem: how to give it to a ton of friends.

    Took the basic recipe, and used it in a sheet pan with 24 tiny tart molds. These came out AMAZING. They overflowed a little, so they look like little cookie muffins. I have to admit, the name makes it sound a little too sweet, but these weren’t! Thanks so much for the great recipe!

  4. Jamie says

    I made the nutella oreo cheesecake pie and the edges of the pie were awesome, but the middle seemed to be undercooked. I wasn’t sure with the cream cheese if that’s the way it was supposed to be or if I did something wrong. Is the consistency of this pie supposed to be like a cookie, or soft?

    • Stephanie says

      It is a bit soft. Sort of a cross between a cookie and cheesecake. Maybe a few more minutes in the oven would give it more of a cookie like texture. I hope you enjoyed it!

  5. Tiffany says

    Holy cow! This looks a- maz-balls! What an exciting combination of flavors! Can’t wait to make it (and then another one for the rest of the family)! Good job!

  6. Joan@Chocolate and More says

    I’m loving the new digs! Just took my shoes off and put my feet on the coffee table, hehe. This pie isn’t just Cheesecake and a cookie having a baby, this is the octo-mom of baking! I have to give this a try! Pinned.

  7. Marianne says

    Love the new site and features. And what a debut recipe. Had to pin it just because of the name (not to mention delish-usness

  8. Mr. Backforseconds says

    Congrats to my wife on her new website! I’m so very proud of you. May your followers grow as vast as my waistline from all your tasty treats! Love you, babe

  9. Hayley @ The Domestic Rebel says

    STEPH!! I LOVE YOUR SITE! OMG OMG OMG. I wish we were celebrating the launch together, drinking cocktails and having fatty slices of this (amazing!!) cookie pie! (It looks amazeballs, btw!) Love this and so so proud of you, friend <3

    • Stephanie says

      Thank you so much, Aimee! I have to check out your new site. I am loving WordPress so far…I have a lot to learn but I am so happy I made the switch!
      Thanks so much for stopping by! 🙂


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.